I was invited here before I looked at the reviews and wasn't expecting much.  Let me say that after reading the reviews, and as a first time customer I think the trick is what you order.  

We ordered several pizzas, including the COB, the fisherman's platter, the breaded wings, and calamari.  The BEST pizza  was the works.. salami, bacon, tomato, peppers, sausage, mushroom and extra cheese.. wow.  I typically don't love pizza (long story short I OD'd on pizza when I worked at a pizza place in college) but I ate this deliciousness the following day for breakfast and lunch.  The French fries were undercooked, but the clams in the fisherman basket were amazing.. as was the blue cheese I can only assume was homemade.  The service was good, our server was accompanied by a few others and they were working hard.

Oh and even for a little "hole in the wall", they still carried Prosecco.. winning!!!

The best part- the prices were very reasonable for this pizza feast- I will be back fo sho.

Read Maggie S.'s review of Red Front Restaurant on Yelp